| Introduction Around June 2007 I began ordering parts for a new custom built pc. The aim was to build a new Quad-Core water cooled PC with the best components
around to build the "ultimate" PC. My previous experience of computer
building consisted of 10 years of cannibalising old PCs and building a Shuttle XPC two years ago. For the uninitiated, Shuttle XPCs are PCs the size of
shoeboxes that consist of motherboard, Case and power supply to which you add
the compatible components of your choice. I was phenomenally proud of my shuttle
and would recommend them to anyone as they are both powerful and reliable (in
the two years I had it it didn't crash once and continues to serve my brother
well).
The inspiration for my new PC was the new Dell XPS. A monster of a machine
with a water cooled quad core extreme processor. I
felt I could build a better PC for less money and this project was an attempt by
me to prove it. My QuadAqua PC would aim to outdo the Dell computer for less
money.
|
| Components The basic components of a PC consist of:
- Case
- Processor (CPU)
- Motherboard
- Graphics Card
- Memory (RAM)
- Hard drive
- Power Supply Unit (PSU)
- Optical Drives
In addition the new PC would need software namely:
- Operating system (OS)
- Office Suite
Normally the price does not lie when buying computer components and my normal
technique would be to find the most expensive components and then check the
reviews for them. Once I had made my decision I would then surf the net to find
the cheapest price for the component. This approach ensured I always had quality
items at the cheapest price.
|
| Case Cases can range from the basic box to more expensive options. The case I
chose was the Thermaltake Tai-Chi VB50001SNA. This aluminium case contains a
liquid cooling system built onto the inside of the case that would save me
having to buy a separate cooling component. It also offered six spaces for
drives giving me massive potential to expand. I checked a few reviews online
that were all favourable. The size of the box when it arrived was still a
surprise though.

Total Cost: £218.55
Postage £14.51
|
| CPU The Intel Extreme processors represent the high end of the market in terms of
performance and price. The Dell XPS comes with a QX6700, so I made the decision
to go for the processor above this. The QX6800 was the best desktop processor on
the market (though a new QX6850 is shortly to replace it) so this would give me
a performance edge over the Dell without the need to overclock. By waiting until
the Intel Price drops in July and shopping around I was able to save over £150
though it still proved to be the most expensive component for something that is
about twice the size of a postal stamp!
Total Cost £608.87
Postage: 8.57
|
| Motherboard The motherboard is the most important part of a computer since it controls
every other part which needs to fit into it. My sole requirements were it needed to be quad-core supporting and either BTX or ATX size since the case could support either. An "Ultimate" pc needed an
"ultimate" motherboard and I eventually settled on a Asus Striker Extreme.
This motherboard whilst expensive offered BIOS overclocking settings and I was
impressed with the number of other options like you can modify the first BIOS screen
picture and
it even has a music alarm!. However the reviews were mixed. There seemed to be a
lot of problems with the motherboard in the support forums (mostly concerning
memory) and the CPU list did not include the more powerful QX6800 I wanted to
use. However using the forums available on the Asus website I was able to
confirm the motherboard did support this (and the day after my post the CPU list
on the Asus website was updated). The memory compatibility was still a worry
though. The motherboard supported SLI so could give me the same as the Dell XPS.
The motherboard also had an onboard
soundcard meaning it was not necessary to purchase this separately.

Total Cost: £182.65
Postage: £2.94
|
| Graphics Card Nvidia have been around for ages it seems though in all my computers I have
always had ATI Radeons. The best graphics card around at the moment is the
Geforce 8800 Ultra. There seemed to be a lot of varieties of these that all had
similar specs so in the end I chose the XFX version with 768MB. This would give
me an awesome graphics card to start, with the option to use SLI to double it up
later on.
Total Cost: £411.19
Postage: £7.34
|
| RAM RAM was something I had always taken for granted. Buy the memory sticks and
plug them in simple. Although there is faster RAM available I chose a special
offer OCZ 2GB Git Platinum DD2 PC6400 800MHZ. I duly bought 4GB and then read
the motherboard compatibility list and realised it wasn't on there. Thankfully
the guys at OCZ have an excellent support forum that specified the settings
needed for it to work on the motherboard though a BIOS release before I built
the PC meant I didn't have to change anything.

Total Cost: £129.23
Postage: £7.34
|
| Hard Drives All my previous Hard drives had been the older IDE variety where you plug in
a ribbon and a power cord and partition the disk how you want. For this PC I
wanted to use a striped SATA RAID array. RAID stands for Redundant Array of
Independent Drives (or Disks) and basically involves multiple hard drives being
linked and being treated as a single unit. This can be used for error correction
or copying the same disks called Mirroring to allow fault tolerance. The
Striping array I wanted was pure performance based where data is stored on
different disks so accessing it is quicker since each hard drive can retrieve its
data separately. Again a special offer saw me buy two Samsung SpinPoint T 500GB
72090RPM SATA 3GB/s 16MB Cache. This would give me a Terabyte of hard disk space
plus the performance.
Total Cost: £136.30
Package: Free
|
| PSU The choice of power supply needed some investigation since I had only ever
bought a replacement one before so had no idea what I should be looking for.
Eventually after reading a few articles the importance of the PSU suddenly
became more apparent. If the power supply was insufficient then the system would
suffer by say the DVD player stalling while power was needed by the graphics
card etc. Since the water cooler on my case needed power and I had already
anticipated one of the state of the art graphics cards I needed some serious
power. I eventually chose the ThermalTake Toughpower 1200w. This beast of a
power supply would give me the option of powering the two graphics cards should
I choose to use the SLI feature of the motherboard. It was also modular meaning
I would only need to connect the cables I actually needed.

Total Cost: £176.19
Postage: £7.34
|
| Accessories LG DVD RW GSA-H44NBRL 18X DVD +/-R/RW/RAM DL IDE
Chosen for its Vista 64 bit compatibility
Total Cost: £18.17
Postage: £2.94
Floppy Drive + Card Reader: £17.79
Postage: £2.15
Total Cost: £35.96
Postage: £5.09
|
| Operating System 64bit capable systems have been around for years but the move to the 64bit
operating system and its need for 64bit drivers and software has meant this has
not yet caught the mainstream buyers attention yet. To use the full power of all
four processors on the Quad Core, Windows Vista was the operating system of
choice (Windows XP supports only two processors). By choosing the 64bit Home
Premium version I had access to the full 4GB of RAM I had already purchased. On
the downside this presented several headaches. Firstly all drivers
have to be 64bit. This meant a lot of my existing hardware
(scanners/printers/network adapters) would be unusable. I had already bought a
new Belkin MIMO usb adapter that was not compatible and meant I had to sacrifice
it for an inferior but compatible Zyxel G202 wireless adapter. In addition
several of my applications would no longer work either. Office 2000 (see below)
and Visual Studio 2003 would both be lost to me with the move to the new OS.
Total Cost: £65.79
Postage: £4.74
|
| Office Suite The use of Vista as an operating system finally meant an end to my student
licensed Office 2000 professional and meant I had to replace it. This meant
another hefty expense. The new Office 2007 package however included Outlook 2007
which would finally allow both hotmail and Pop3 email accounts to be monitored
(Outlook Express had this functionality for years but Outlook - the more
expensive fuller version did not).
Total Cost: £351.98
Postage: £8.99
|
| Other Items Microsoft Multimedia Keyboard and Optical Mouse: £16.85(+£2.15
postage)
Benq 22inch Widescreen Monitor £211.19 (+Free Postage)
Zyxel G202 wireless adapter £4.99 (+£3 postage)
Speakers £25.99 (+£9.99 postage)
|
Total Costs
| |
Cost |
Postage |
|
Case |
218.55 |
14.51 |
|
Motherboard |
182.65 |
2.94 |
|
PSU |
176.19 |
7.34 |
|
CPU |
608.87 |
8.57 |
|
Graphics Card |
411.19 |
7.34 |
|
RAM |
129.23 |
4.64 |
|
DVD RW |
18.17 |
2.94 |
|
Vista |
65.79 |
4.64 |
|
Hard Drives |
136.30 |
0.00 |
|
Office |
351.98 |
8.99 |
|
Monitor |
211.19 |
0.00 |
|
Speakers |
25.99 |
9.99 |
|
USB Adapter |
4.99 |
3.00 |
|
Multi-drive |
17.79 |
2.53 |
|
Multimedia Keyboard + Optical Mouse |
16.85 |
2.53 |
|
Total |
2575.73 |
79.96 |
|
| Assembly So after 10 weeks of ordering parts in it was time for the fun to begin and
put it all together. The instruction manual for the case and water cooling was far from perfect.
Basic instructions were given in vague terms so it would take trial and error
(and probably some luck) for it all to work perfectly straight away. I thought
it was important to get all the components onto the motherboard first and worry
about cutting the pipes to the right size afterwards. So after working out that
the motherboard tray needed some copper screws between it and the motherboard
and installing the CPU, water block and RAM the motherboard was ready to be
installed into the case.

This is where we hit our first glitch. The motherboard tray had to be slid
onto the case but it was very difficult to get this into place with the
motherboard covering the hooks. In the end we
took out the left side of the case and attached the motherboard to it, before
attaching it back into the case. We then cut the cooling tubes to the right side
and attached them to the water pump.

The i/o shield clipped in nicely, and the power supply slotted in and was
screwed in with no problems. The hard disks were tricky to attach to the cage
but again slipped in ok. The card reader/floppy drive combination needed to
connect to an onboard USB which was out of range of the top slot on the case but
luckily this could be moved down to reach. All the other connectors were
attached with little or no problem. Then we came to the graphics card. This
monster (taking up two PCI slots) simply would not fit in to the expansion card
push-click mechanism of the case and we had to remove the plastic connectors put
the card in and then reattach the plastic connectors.
|
Firing it Up
After filling up the coolant tank we were ready for power on, about 2hours
after we had begun building. We stepped back and pressed the power on
button......only for nothing to happen. Well not nothing...a closer inspection
revealed some blue LED lights to come on the motherboard. We disconnected the
non-essential components and tried again with the same result. It was
tremendously disappointing and an anti-climax after the build up. After an hour
of searching through the Asus website we found a reference to turning off the
LED switch and a check of the manual did confirm that it had instructed us to
press this button at the beginning (I really should read the instructions
carefully BEFORE installing stuff). Doing so allowed the system to power on with
the fans buzzing in a blue light and the sight of some air bubbles moving
towards the water block. However the system switched itself off after about 10
seconds. We quickly discovered through the BIOS that the CPU temperature was
rising rapidly and the system was switching off after it peaked at 100 degrees.
The water cooling was clearly not performing and closer inspection showed that
there were massive gaps of air in the tubes that was preventing the coolant from
reaching the water block. We switched off and topped up and switched off and
topped up noticing the bubbles each time. Eventually we decided to drain the
systems (my brother breaking the disappointment with a joke about bleeding
pipes!). Through trial and error we managed to get the system on with a flow of
water but the CPU temperature was around 65 degrees still too hot. Again we
drained the system again and managed this time managed to get almost all the
pipes filled with water before we screwed it to the pump. This time the CPU
temperature never went beyond 40 degrees. However bleeding the pipes again
allowed the temperature to go as low as 29degrees idle. Before we could congratulate ourselves
however we realised we couldn't shut the side door with the size of the graphics
card and the radiator on the door.
With the 8800 Ultra
With the 8800 GTX
At first we thought the solution may be to replace the fan on the graphics
card with a new cooling solution that would take less space though the Ultra was
a brand new graphics card and the custom cooling solutions used the same space
as the existing fan. We could have drilled new holes in the case and moved the
cooling system on the door up but again this wasn't particularly attractive. The
solution was to order a new slightly less powerful GTX model and sell the Ultra
model on Ebay.
|
| Conclusion My aim in building the QuadAqua was to construct a PC that was better than
the Dell XPS for less money. I therefore went on the Dell website and customised
an XPS to make it as similar to the QuadAqua to compare the price:
| |
QuadAqua |
Dell XPS |
| Processor |
Intel® Core™ 2 Quad-Core QX6800 Extreme Processor
(2.97GHz,1066MHz,8MB cache) |
Intel® Core™ 2 Quad-Core QX6700 Extreme Processor
(2.66GHz,1066MHz,8MB cache) |
| Operating System |
Genuine Windows Vista™ Home Premium (64-Bit)- English |
Genuine Windows Vista™ Home Premium (32-Bit)- English |
| Monitor |
BenQ 22" Silver Wide Flat Panel display (FP222WH) |
Dell™ 22" Black Wide Flat Panel (E228WFP) |
| RAM |
4096MB 800MHZ Dual Channel DDR2 SDRAM [4x1024] |
4096MB 667MHz Dual Channel DDR2 SDRAM [4x1024] |
| Hard Drive |
1TB Serial ATA RAID 0 Stripe (2x500GB 7200rpm drives with DataBurst™
cache) |
1TB Serial ATA RAID 0 Stripe (2x500GB 7200rpm drives with DataBurst™
cache) |
| Optical Drive |
18x DVD+/-RW |
16x DVD+/-RW |
| Graphics Card |
SINGLE 768MB nVidia® GeForce® 8800 GTX graphics card |
SINGLE 768MB nVidia® GeForce® 8800 GTX graphics card |
| Media Reader |
Internal 7-in-1 Media Card Reader |
Internal 13-in-1 Media Card Reader |
| Floppy Drive |
Yes |
Yes |
| Speaker |
Logitech S500 5.1 surround sound speaker system |
Creative Inspire T7900 7.1 Speaker System |
| Office Suite |
Microsoft® Office 2007 Professional - English |
Microsoft® Office 2007 Professional - English |
| |
|
|
| Total Cost (inc P&P) |
£2,616.00 |
£3,026.84 |
However the table is misleading in many ways. Dell's provides an excellent
warranty service and comes with a lot of extra software. Whilst the motherboard
did provide an anti-virus and other software it wasn't Vista compatible so was
lost. Nevertheless the QuadAqua contains a more powerful processor and faster
RAM for £400 cheaper than the Dell so the project was successful in that way.
What is also worth noting is I wasted £450+ on a graphics card that
didn't fit and a wireless module that wasn't compatible with Vista 64.
Not only that but Dell released a new version of teh XPS with very
similar stats to the QuadAqua shortly after I had finished building
which cost around £4000.
Lessons learned:
- Shop around. The internet really does mean you can find parts literally
hundreds of pounds cheaper.
- Always read the instructions before assembly. Sounds obvious but
so tempting to just dive in.
- Use online support forums for advice. Chances are someone has tried
something you are trying or has experienced the same problem. Special
mention for the OCZ memory forum which gave clear advice on what
settings to use. Top notch!
- Be patient. The water cooling took about three days to optimise
and remove all the air pockets. This was probably due to the
insufficient instructions but it was worth it when the processor
never goes above 40degrees!
- Do your homework. Deciding on Vista 64bit for example meant a lot of
checking whether certain components were compatible. By doing this before I
bought them meant not having the disappointment of finding out after
building and installing. I may also have been prevented from finding out the
graphics card didn't fit!
|
|
|